| I Dream of Mindreading by John Lovick - Trick | Magic Apple | Lovick, John | $15.00 |
| I Hate David Copperfield Trick by Geoff Williams - DVD | Kozmomagic Inc. | Williams, Geoff | $20.00 |
| I-Boss (KEVLAR) by Sorcery Manufacturing - Trick | Sorcery Shop | Sorcery Manufacturing | $15.00 |
| I.M. Bones Royal | Fun, Inc. | | $4.50 |
| Ibidem Volume 1 by P. Howard Lyons - Book | Hermetic Press, Inc. | Lyons, Howard | $60.00 |
| Ibidem Volume 2 by P. Howard Lyons - Book | Hermetic Press, Inc. | Lyons, Howard | $60.00 |
| Ibidem Volume 3 by P. Howard Lyons - Book | Hermetic Press, Inc. | Lyons, Howard | $60.00 |
| IBoss (WOOLY) Ultra Thin Thread by Sorcery Manufacturing - Trick | Sorcery Shop | Sorcery Manufacturing | $15.00 |
| Ice Breakers (with Cards) by Michael Ammar - DVD | Michael Ammar Magic, LLC | Ammar,Michael | $35.00 |
| Ice Coins (W/ DVD, UK 2 Pound Size) by Christopher Congreave - Trick | Alakazam UK | Congreave, Christopher | $39.00 |
| Ice Coins (W/ DVD, USA Half Dollar) by Christopher Congreave - Trick | Alakazam UK | Congreave, Christopher | $39.00 |
| Ice From Water by Andrew Gerard - Trick | Andrew Gerard Henderson | Gerard, Andrew | $75.00 |
| Iced Over by Russ DeSimone and Ed Bedrick - Trick | Edward Bedrick | DeSimone, Russ; Bedrick, Ed | $25.00 |
| Ickle Pickle Nickle - Trick | Ickle Pickle Products, Inc. | | $4.00 |
| Idea Factory Volume 1 by By Dean Montalbano and Leaping Lizards - Book | Leaping Lizards Publishing (V) | Montalbano, Dean | $25.00 |
| Ideal Magician's Pen by Di Fatta - Trick | Vincenzo Di Fatta (V) | | $9.98 |
| iDeck By Noel Qualter and Alakazam - Trick | Alakazam UK | Qualter, Noel | $80.00 |
| Idem by Magix Effect - Trick | MagixEffect | Rudolf, Julien | $19.95 |
| Identity (With Gimmicks) by Richard Sanders - DVD | Richard Sanders | Sanders, Richard | $29.95 |
| iFloat, The Impromptu Floating Cell Phone - DVD | Magic City | | $24.95 |
